For a spray that kills spiders on contact, compare the TERRO aerosol, which lists black widows, brown recluses, and hobo spiders, with Raid MAX, which lists household spiders and black widows. Ortho Home Defense is better suited to people seeking a longer-lasting indoor and perimeter barrier, while Raid Multi Insect Killer handles a broader range of pests. The peppermint-oil product is a repellent, not a spider-killing spray.
| Product | Best For | Key Distinction |
|---|---|---|
| Raid MAX Spider & Scorpion | Indoor and outdoor spider control | Lists household spiders and black widows |
| TERRO Insect Killer Aerosol | Contact killing of listed spider types | Lists black widow, brown recluse, and hobo spiders |
| Ortho Home Defense | Indoor and perimeter treatment | Up to 12 months of protection indoors on non-porous surfaces against listed pests |
| Raid Multi Insect Killer | Multiple common household pests | Contact spray for spiders and many other insects |
| Peppermint Oil Repellent | Repelling rather than killing spiders | Plant-based repellent for indoor and outdoor areas |
Raid MAX Spider & Scorpion Insect Killer
Best for: People looking for a spray specifically described for spiders and scorpions, with indoor and outdoor use listed. This 12-ounce aerosol kills bugs on contact and names household spiders and black widow spiders among its targets. It also lists ants and roaches.
Choose this if you want a focused spider-control product rather than a general-purpose spray. It is a better match than a broad insect spray when the listed targets align with the pest problem. The supplied product details do not list brown recluse or hobo spiders, so do not assume those are covered.
TERRO Spider, Ant, Roach, And Insect Killer
Best for: Buyers prioritizing a contact spray whose listed targets include several named spider types. The two-pack aerosol kills on contact and lists black widow, brown recluse, and hobo spiders, along with ants, cockroaches, crickets, scorpions, and other insects.
Choose TERRO if those specific spider names matter to your comparison. Its stated action is contact killing, so the supplied details do not establish long-term residual protection after application. Follow the product label for use and precautions.
Ortho Home Defense Indoor And Perimeter Spray
Best for: Homeowners treating recurring problem areas such as doors, windows, foundations, patios, decks, and garages. The 1.33-gallon ready-to-use product includes a battery-powered Comfort Wand for continuous spraying. Its listed indoor protection lasts up to 12 months against ants, roaches, and spiders on non-porous surfaces.
Choose this if coverage and a spray barrier are more important than a small contact-kill aerosol. The long-lasting claim applies to the named pests and indoor non-porous surfaces; the supplied features do not make the same duration claim for every outdoor area or surface.
Raid Multi Insect Killer Orange Breeze
Best for: People who want one contact spray for spiders and a wide selection of crawling and flying insects. This 15-ounce can lists spiders, ants, roaches, fleas, silverfish, mosquitoes, flies, and other pests. It is described for use indoors and outdoors and has an orange breeze scent.
Choose this if a multi-insect product fits your household needs better than a spider-focused formula. The important limitation is explicit: it does not kill brown recluse or black widow spiders. The product description says the scent does not leave a lingering chemical odor.
Peppermint Oil Insect And Spider Repellent
Best for: Buyers seeking a plant-based product intended to deter spiders and insects in places such as kitchens, bathrooms, garages, gardens, patios, and vehicles. The 16-ounce spray is described as suitable for indoor and outdoor use and as safe for pets and children when applied as directed.
This is not the right choice if your main goal is to kill a spider on contact: its product description presents it as a repellent. The supplied details do not provide a specific duration for its protection, so compare its label directions with your treatment needs.
Buying Guide: How To Choose Spider Spray
Do you need contact killing or continued protection?
Contact sprays such as Raid MAX and TERRO are described as killing bugs on contact. Ortho is the option in this group with a stated long-lasting indoor protection period, but that claim is limited to listed pests on non-porous surfaces. Check the label to understand where and how each product can be applied.
Which spider types does the product name?
Compare the listed targets instead of assuming all spider sprays cover every species. TERRO names black widow, brown recluse, and hobo spiders. Raid MAX names black widow and household spiders. Raid Multi Insect Killer explicitly excludes brown recluse and black widow spiders from its spider-killing claim.
Where will you apply the spray?
For indoor and outdoor use, Raid MAX and Raid Multi Insect Killer list both settings. Ortho identifies specific indoor and outdoor treatment areas, including kitchens, bathrooms, doors, windows, and foundation perimeters. The peppermint-oil product also lists indoor and outdoor spaces, but it is intended to repel.
Do you want to treat more than spiders?
Raid Multi Insect Killer and TERRO list a range of additional pests. Ortho is suited to barrier treatment for ants, roaches, and spiders. Match the product’s named pests to the problem rather than choosing solely by the word “spider” on the package.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which spray in this list names brown recluse spiders?
TERRO lists brown recluse spiders among the insects its aerosol kills on contact. Raid Multi Insect Killer explicitly excludes brown recluse spiders.
Which product lists black widow spiders?
TERRO and Raid MAX list black widow spiders. Raid Multi Insect Killer excludes them from its spider-killing claim.
Does peppermint oil spray kill spiders?
The peppermint-oil product is described as a spider and insect repellent. Its supplied features do not say that it kills spiders on contact.
Which option provides a stated long-lasting indoor barrier?
Ortho Home Defense states up to 12 months of indoor protection against ants, roaches, and spiders when applied to non-porous surfaces.
Can these sprays be used around pets and children?
The peppermint-oil product says it is safe around pets and children when applied as directed. For every product, follow its label directions and precautions before use.