The James Madison Presidential dollar is a modern U.S. coin honoring the fourth president, not a coin minted during his presidency from 1809 to 1817. Among these listings, the 2007 P-and-D two-coin sets are best for collectors seeking both mint varieties, while the 2007 S proof is best for a proof-style display. The related album can hold Presidential dollars, but coins are not included. The other two listings contain older U.S. coins, not James Madison dollars.
| Product | Best For | What To Know |
|---|---|---|
| 2007 P,D Satin Finish Set | Two-mint collecting | Two coins in an archival-safe flip |
| 2007 S Proof Dollar | Proof-style collecting | Single coin in a 2-by-2 flip |
| 2007 P,D Uncirculated Set | Basic two-coin collecting | Two coins in cardboard holders |
| Presidential Dollar Album | Organizing a collection | Coins are not included |
| 1800s Penny and Nickel Set | Broader U.S. coin history | Not a Madison-era coin set |
2007 P,D Satin Finish James Madison Dollar Set
This two-coin set is best for collectors who want the listed Philadelphia and Denver mint issues together. The product description identifies the coins as satin finish and brilliant uncirculated, and says they come in a 2-by-2 archival-safe flip.
It was selected because it combines two James Madison Presidential dollars in one listing and specifies the storage format. Choose this if a paired set and protective flip matter more than having a single proof coin. The listing describes the coins as uncirculated, but it does not provide individual grading details.
2007 S Proof James Madison Presidential Dollar
This single 2007 S proof dollar is best for collectors who prefer a proof-designated coin rather than a two-mint set. The listing calls it a GEM proof and says it is packaged in a 2-by-2 archival-safe flip.
It was selected as the clearest option for a buyer specifically looking for a proof James Madison dollar. Choose this if you want one proof coin for a focused collection or display. Unlike the paired listings, it does not provide both P and D coins. The product description does not state a numerical grade.
2007 P,D James Madison Uncirculated Two-Coin Set
This listing is best for buyers seeking a straightforward P-and-D pair of James Madison Presidential dollars. Its features identify a two-coin set and say the coins are sent in 2-by-2 cardboard holders.
It was selected as a second paired-coin option because it offers both listed mint issues while specifying its included holders. Choose this if cardboard holders suit your storage plans. The listing does not describe a satin finish or an archival-safe flip, so buyers seeking those specific details may prefer the first set.
Presidential Dollar Album And Presidents Book
This album is best for collectors who want a place to organize Presidential dollars alongside introductory presidential history. The product description says the holder displays a president’s image and that the accompanying paperback book has 48 pages of history and information about U.S. presidents.
The album measures 11 by 10 inches closed and 11 by 20 inches open. It was selected as a practical companion to the Madison dollar listings, not as a coin purchase. Important limitation: coins are not included, so buyers need to obtain the Madison dollar separately.
1800s Indian Head Penny And Liberty Head Nickel
This set is best for collectors interested in other historic U.S. coins, not for someone seeking a James Madison Presidential dollar. Its listed coins are an Indian Head penny and a Liberty Head nickel in sonically sealed acrylic, with dates and mint marks that vary. The listing says the coins are from the 1800s and includes a Certificate of Authenticity.
It was selected only as a broader historical coin alternative among the supplied products. The dates of these coin designs postdate Madison’s presidency, so do not mistake this set for a coin issued between 1809 and 1817. The variable dates and mint marks also mean the exact examples can differ.
Buying Guide: Choosing A James Madison Coin
Was a James Madison dollar made during 1809–1817?
The products listed here are 2007 Presidential dollars honoring James Madison. They are not coins from his presidency. If you are researching money used during 1809–1817, verify the coin’s date and historical issue separately rather than relying on a modern commemorative design.
Should you choose a proof or an uncirculated set?
Choose the 2007 S proof listing if you want a single coin specifically described as a GEM proof. Choose a P-and-D set if you want two mint issues together. The satin-finish set specifies an archival-safe flip; the other P-and-D listing specifies cardboard holders.
What should you check before buying?
- Confirm the listing says James Madison and identifies the year and mint marks you want.
- Check whether it contains one coin or two, and read the stated holder or packaging details.
- Look for a numerical grade only if you require one; these supplied descriptions do not give a numerical grade.
- For the album, remember that the coins are not included.
Frequently Asked Questions
What year is the James Madison Presidential dollar?
The products listed here identify the James Madison Presidential dollar as a 2007 coin.
Is the 2007 James Madison dollar from his presidency?
No. It is a modern Presidential dollar honoring Madison, whose presidency lasted from 1809 to 1817.
What does P,D mean in a coin listing?
In these product descriptions, P and D identify the Philadelphia and Denver mint issues included in the two-coin set.
Does the Presidential dollar album include a Madison coin?
No. The album listing states that coins are not included.
Are the 1800s penny and nickel Madison coins?
No. That set contains an Indian Head penny and a Liberty Head nickel, not a James Madison Presidential dollar.